Friday, 22 August 2014

5. Apparently, the fear of being left behind is Athazagoraphobia

Reading Langdon Winner's article 'Utopia or Dystopia?', I was struck by a phrase Christopher Horrocks says in his book “Marshall McLuhan and Virtuality” which is 'the message is the medium' (reversing McLuhan's famous phrase. What Horrocks is referring to is that new mediums are increasingly being conceived in their usefulness to their audience, though Horrocks discusses the helpful multi-model format the internet is taking. In contrast, near the end of his article Winner looks pessimistically at how technologies such as digital spinal cords in supermarkets, able to instantly take stock of their inventories, to distill data about efficient selling. Winner notes that the true costs are not being calculated- rather that the prices of certain items, the true cost is local retailers in favour of chain stores of Big Business. This transaction is weakening social structures, as local retailers are pillars of communities.
Winner's own view of cyberlibertarianism forms a hollow look at technological advancement, considering progression to be marginalizing large groups of people who do not wish to play active roles in this upheaval of systems. I do agree with Winner's criticism of earlier observations that technology is evolving in a uni-linear fashion, as do I agree that the semantics of a bio-technical evolution creates the impression that Technology with a capital T (like Politics with a capital P) is its own species distinct of human agency.

Jeremy Rifkin's article 'The Rise of Anti-Capitalism' has quite a joyous outlook on technological progress; humans will move from private profiteering corporations to non-profit enterprises. Rifkin sees this progress as something that will unify and communalize society in order to create charities and networks which will forego economic transactions in favour of inclusive communities who share. Winner's article accuses people like Rifkin, those who have plentiful access to technology, to be susceptible to blindly embracing these new paths of development as they construct a promotion of power to those who easily obtain a step up in the world of digital networks, unwilling to consider the detriment of those who do not obviously benefit. Rifkin, in Winner's perspective, does not consider the layman whose status quo has been to engage in stable monotonous labour.

Saturday, 16 August 2014

To Censure Cyborgs

In N Katherine Hayles' article “Unfinished Work: From Cyborg to Cognisphere”, Hayles' idea of the human and post-human being labels which fall under the fluid purview of history and context rather than “a stable ontology”. Hayles considers there to be four historical epochs of her historical model, “first-order cybernetics from 1945 to 1960, autopoiesis or second-order cybernetics from 1960 to 1985, and virtuality or third-order cybernetics from 1985 to 1995, have now progressed to a fourth stage that [is] the Regime of Computation”. This Regime of Computation can be equivocated to the posthuman in that they are both checkpoints in which we should begin to think about our conceptualization of technological advancement from cyborg to cognisphere- “the cognisphere gives a name and shape to the globally interconnected cognitive systems in which humans are increasingly embedded”. This shift in the way we think about the outline of technological advancement can be thought of as switching from Victor Stone to Barbara Gordon's Oracle (I hope somebody's getting these references). The role that machines are coming to play in their interaction with humans is one that is shifting because the augmentation of machines is developing more towards an externalized input of technology bestowing information, than an internalized output of humans interacting with technology.
The other thing I would like to chat about is Adam Curtis's 2011 documentary “All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace”. It was an engaging and intelligent critique of ecosystem theory, about how describing systems via vegetational concepts dramatically oversimplifies the complexity of nature, and the myth of feedback loops creating steady state systems was particularly numbing. What was really intriguing to me, however, was that it was a documentary geared for a general populace with no formal education in techno-culture or ubiquitous media. Like Trekkies about the latter half of the Star Trek film series, academics usually discredit the idea that mass-appealing and widely-engaging texts has any intellectual currency. I believe they are wrong. There seems to be a general sense in circles of the highly-educated that there is an inverse correlation between the complexities of ideas and the amount of appreciation that can be garnered from an audience, but as with these ecosystems, and to quote brothers John and Hank Green, “the truth resists simplicity”.

Friday, 8 August 2014

3. Happy Hermeneutics


In Ihde's article “A Phenomenology of Technics”, he discusses hermeneutic process by which we interact with technology, and explores the transparency and opacity of technics. I agree with him, and even go so far as to say that the hermeneutic relationships we have with technology have specific transparencies encoded within the generation of our culture and here's why-
My mother is from Generation X. She recently was gifted an iPhone from my sister, which, as you will no doubt be aware, has a touchscreen interface (the Apple product, not my sibling) - [see, I don't even have to tell you the rest of that story because based on the facts given, and your ability to extrapolate, you know where this is heading. I suppose for marks, I'll have to spell it out anyway. Also, this section of the blog is not counting towards my word count and will be redacted in final submission] you would think that given the fact that the legacy of technology inherited by the Millenials comes from Generation X, that my mother would understand how touchscreens would work.
It's been three days and my mother's sole usage of the iPhone with the digital interface into a flashlight, a somewhat less complex interface. Ihde discusses how shamanism is a form of hermeneutics. If you've ever seen the utter ineptness of someone with a smartphone, shamanism comes off pretty favourably by comparison.
So where does the humour come from? I would say the transparency coded into the Millenials in touchscreens, intuitively able to swipe Grindr photos or play Angry Birds was only witnessed by the Gen Xers in the Starship Enterprise. We've all seen that cartoon clip where Wile E. Coyote chases Road Runner- Road Runner runs through into the diegesis of a painting of a tunnel while the Coyote squashes his face on the painting's surface. The joke is the same, but the stakes are much higher. Now, I'm not saying that the hop from analogue to digital was the only hermeneutic change to technology that we've ever faced- since inscription of any kind, we've had hermeneutics and every technology after that required a unique process of embodiment and interface. Technology, and indeed its phenomenological relationship with humans, is one of a legacy, and like those before us, we should make sure we know what we're comfortable with before we pass it on. In the meantime, I'm happy to allow my mother to hideously grapple with the iPhone.

ALL HAIL THE FAMOUS GROUSE


Saturday, 2 August 2014

Interfering with the Interface


In Alexander R. Galloway's article “The Unworkable Interface” (my favourite of the three readings of the week), Galloway notes that new media in the form of the web, cybernetics and “significant surfaces” as being quite unique at this point in history, pioneering the way in which the digital interface is characterized in order to cope with the cacophony of format articulations of the internet. The internet has no real definitive edge in terms of medium (as all mediums have fluid boundaries), Galloway discusses, and the interface is responsible for dealing with this issue. If you watch the hilarity that is the video in the link posted above, you might agree. Though the example I have chosen is hyperbolic, it demonstrates that the interface of Instant Messaging might be considered a predecessor for Drucker's stance on interface with an extension from the object to the environment. There's a quote from the novel The Go-Between- “the past is another country. They do things differently there”. Galloway seems to agree with this.
In Drucker's article, the focal point of discussion is on the dynamics and perception of interface through graphic representations and frame analysis. Drucker's logic and insight into the human-computer interface is interesting, but ultimately unexciting. However, his inclusion of graphical reading processes, especially of Scott McCloud's work, seems quite glossed over- though I can live with it as I understand Drucker is making a point about the shift in a subject's behaviour in viewing a digital interface. Drucker does not spend much time unpacking what frame analysis is, though I understand a certain amount of bricolage taking place. His application of frame analysis acts as a way of organizing cognitive processes and experiences before generating meaning.
My research project is still fermenting on its focus, although after reading Drucker I would like to try my hand in something about the human-computer interface experience in online communities. Finally, this poem was interesting- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gu_PQBmk-6c


ALL HAIL THE BURGER KING