Sunday, 12 October 2014

To Ratify Reviews and Pen Proposals

My final essay begins to define itself- a comparative analysis between the well-established social-networking site Facebook and the newly-released Ello, dubbed by several sources to be the “anti-Facebook”. My main point of interest is the conscious structuring by the latter to disenfranchise notions of pervasive surveillance in the former. Ello's manifesto reads as a declaration for the evils of social-networking being funded by advertising, as this necessitates data-mining in order to best choose commercials for users. Paradoxically, clicking the 'I agree' button gives you the option of sharing this manifesto on these same networks. Laconically, clicking the 'I disagree' button takes you to Facebook's terms and conditions. My analysis will assess four major areas- ethics of data mining and cloud storage of data and implications of privacy, interface design and medium intensity, accessibility (and exclusivity), and user connectivity. My main investigation will be determining the validity of the innovations that Ello has attempted, contrasting my original observations and quotations from Ello staff, with academic literature concerning Facebook, as well as other articles on interface and digital media.
The conscious attempt made by Ello to distinguish itself from Facebook stretches from its ethics (they refuse to take any personal information over a user other than an email) to the aesthetic interface being a drag brown in contrast to Facebook's pale blue. I would argue that Ello seeks for the “hipster” characterization of both itself and its users, attempting to be different for the purpose of being different.

As for my review on FTVMS 717, I believe that the course was certainly one that benefited from the department name-change to Media, Film and Television. Having deliberately chosen undergraduate media papers which favoured analysis of films and television over more conceptual or “real world” processes, I was well-challenged over the philosophical and more futurology-related readings. Structurally, I think the topic-order was quite sound. My one complaint was probably the venue, which could have been in a room more conducive to talk about the future, rather than the past (or the air conditioning).

Saturday, 4 October 2014

To Interrogate the In-Between Spaces

In Anne Galloway's 2010 article “Intimations of everyday life: Ubiquitous computing and the city”, Galloway discusses the social and cultural implications which the techno-political influences of ubiquitous media may generate. Galloway opens her article noting that her piece is meant to ask more questions than answer them, and at the very least, she does just that.
The main point of interest in Galloway's article is her discussion over applications which allow urban environments to be overlaid with augmented virtuality, such as Urban Tapestries which allows users to digitally annotate areas in their environment, and Tejp which allows users to implant audio messages into the spaces around them. Galloway's tone gives an ambivalent impression on the effects that using Ubicomp in everyday life might have- concluding with a question mark over how people will relate to each other, “move” through spaces, and interpret the intensities of augmented realities and virtualities.
One query Galloway articulates is the “visibility” of ubiquitous media- wherein the attention shifts from the periphery to the centre of the user's focus. Galloway notes that media will, in public spaces, grow more invisible with technological innovation. You can find examples of this when you find people making the pilgrimage from their private domiciles to the city by public transport, using AT Hop cards. The Hop cards are largely invisible, track the location of its user, and remove the need to speak to the bus driver, creating a more “efficient” travel. However, as Galloway discusses a sinister side to ubiquitous media in our enviornments, so to does the Hop. Hop cards must be tagged on and off the bus; failing to tag off results in a financial penalty usually matching the bus fare itself. I cannot understand the logic of this penalty, except that by training folks to tag off as well as on, it must be collecting some large census data about public transport flows in Auckland.

If you're a town planner or the owner of a taxi firm, I bet that's valuable information.

Sunday, 28 September 2014

To Conquer the Cloud

David Lametti's 'The Cloud: Boundless Digital Potential or Enclosure 3.0?' discusses the implications' discusses the implications of cloud storage systems and their privatization being contradictory to the ethos intrinsic to the apparatus of the Internet. Lametti considers the idea of Cloud storage to “enclose” intellectual properties in a way that the vast ocean of cyberspace cannot be, as Clouds are owned and restrictions (“choke points”) can be placed to survey who has access.
Privacy for users of cloud storage is another major issue for Lametti. One example spawned from this reaction to user-privacy is Ello, a new social networking site, deemed the “anti-Facebook” for its staunch refusal to display advertisements to users, maintaining that the current practice necessitates data-mining to find “relevant” advertisements for users. While Facebook does not hide the fact that it routinely uses sentiment analysis and manipulation of data on its site, Ello goes as far as to consider that the “Like” button acts as a means of Facebook collecting information on a person.
Another thing Lametti worries about is companies owning storage clouds and making encryption cyphers to restrict access, but I would argue that encryption can be used both ways. When I used to download from Megaupload, I used to get Doctor Who Big Finish CDs because I was unable to legally purchase them in NZ. The files themselves were uploaded as completely random strings of numbers, unable to be detected from the prying eyes of the litigious BBC. To avoid connecting the Megaupload pages with corresponding stories, a forum developed with an encryption of its own which would circumvent computer programs from systematically detecting them using key phrases.
“The Five Companions” was “Friends Slightly Less Than Six”.
“Death Comes to Time” was “No-Life Arrives at Clock-Quantity”.
“Legend of the Cybermen” was “Myths about Metal People”.

Etc cetera. Lametti seems worried that humans will run out of ingenuity to circumvent access to the cloud. I reckon it's too early to tell. 

Saturday, 20 September 2014

To Preen Paranoia

Harper’s article “The Politics of Paranoia: Paranoid Positioning and Conspiratorial Narratives in the Surveillance Society” discusses the changing paradigm of paranoia and its relation to technologically-advancing surveillance. His inquiry into “paranoia culture” is very interesting, as it keys in on the fact that the condition of paranoia is one which is mediated through a culture depicting paranoia as a sign of vigilantism or psychosis. I would argue that Harper’s motivation to critique paranoia based on technological surveillance has a great deal of validity, as he notes an increase and growing complexity to paranoia, divorced from the two great Western myths of ubiquitous surveillance- religion, and Santa Claus.
Santa Claus is almost certainly the first form of paranoia to be inundated to people; the paranoia of Santa Claus, who sees you when you’re sleeping and knows when you’re awake, and knows when you’ve been bad or good, forces children to be good for goodness sake. To not be paranoid (on your best behavior) results in the threat of no presents under your Christmas tree. The mode of surveillance is as ubiquitous as current forms of pinhole cameras and computer histories- they are so innocuous and invisible that it is impossible to escape from their view.
The main point Harper makes is that paranoia, while producing feasible explanations due to technology advancing, is that it is often unjustified. Unlike children naively being good for fear of Father Christmas, paranoia is stigmatized, and the act of reclaiming the word seems bizarre to me, for “paranoia” in its original Greek form means “madness”. People should be aware of institutional and domestic surveillance, but given the recent Dotcom parade of the NSA tapping the Southern Cross Cable, New Zealanders seem to shrug with an oh-what-will-they-think-of-next? attitude. Though Dotcom might be paranoid, it all begs the question- who cares if we’re being watched? In a Freudian view of the situation, surveillance generates the greatest paranoids when people think what they’re doing is worthy of punishment.

Get over yourselves.

Sunday, 14 September 2014

6. To Trust the Tamagotchi?

Sherry Turkle's chapter 'nearest neighbours' considers that the way in which humans perceive life and emotional attachment to have fluid boundaries, and that there is has been an active demarcation between the lines of living being and machine, and that the traditional dichotomy between alive and not-alive has been replaced by a spectrum. Turkle considers that children think this way due to technological advancements in toys- her main exemplars are the Furby and the Tamagotchi. What makes these toys unique to other toys, Turkle says, is not that children can easily project personalities, desires and maintenance onto them like ragdolls or action figures. The Furbies and Tamagotchis have their own personalities, desires and maintenance programmed into them and are capable of expressing these feelings to their owners. These expressions do not create a lifelike toy for a child- they create a life, perhaps not as sacred as a biological pet but certainly authentic enough to cherish, care for, and grieve over.
Later in her article, Turkle begins discussing how people who have online presences, in MMORPGs or chat-rooms, use their mobile phone to live their online life and offline life simultaneously (labelled the “life mix”), and what makes the life-mix possible is the ability to be mobile in the physical world (not tethered to a desktop computer which would interrupt the “real” world). I would argue that Turkle misses this point with Furbies and Tamagotchi- you can take them anywhere, unlike a cat or dog most of the time. Another virtual pet, Neopets, came in around the time of Tamagotchi but I would hazard a guess that Tamagotchi can elicit far stronger feelings of intimacy and liveliness. While Neopets are far more customizable and more activities can be performed than Tamagotchi, Neopets have orphanages where unwanted pets can be dumped (demonstrating, at least, that the creators of Neopets have acknowledged a level of disregard).

Friday, 22 August 2014

5. Apparently, the fear of being left behind is Athazagoraphobia

Reading Langdon Winner's article 'Utopia or Dystopia?', I was struck by a phrase Christopher Horrocks says in his book “Marshall McLuhan and Virtuality” which is 'the message is the medium' (reversing McLuhan's famous phrase. What Horrocks is referring to is that new mediums are increasingly being conceived in their usefulness to their audience, though Horrocks discusses the helpful multi-model format the internet is taking. In contrast, near the end of his article Winner looks pessimistically at how technologies such as digital spinal cords in supermarkets, able to instantly take stock of their inventories, to distill data about efficient selling. Winner notes that the true costs are not being calculated- rather that the prices of certain items, the true cost is local retailers in favour of chain stores of Big Business. This transaction is weakening social structures, as local retailers are pillars of communities.
Winner's own view of cyberlibertarianism forms a hollow look at technological advancement, considering progression to be marginalizing large groups of people who do not wish to play active roles in this upheaval of systems. I do agree with Winner's criticism of earlier observations that technology is evolving in a uni-linear fashion, as do I agree that the semantics of a bio-technical evolution creates the impression that Technology with a capital T (like Politics with a capital P) is its own species distinct of human agency.

Jeremy Rifkin's article 'The Rise of Anti-Capitalism' has quite a joyous outlook on technological progress; humans will move from private profiteering corporations to non-profit enterprises. Rifkin sees this progress as something that will unify and communalize society in order to create charities and networks which will forego economic transactions in favour of inclusive communities who share. Winner's article accuses people like Rifkin, those who have plentiful access to technology, to be susceptible to blindly embracing these new paths of development as they construct a promotion of power to those who easily obtain a step up in the world of digital networks, unwilling to consider the detriment of those who do not obviously benefit. Rifkin, in Winner's perspective, does not consider the layman whose status quo has been to engage in stable monotonous labour.

Saturday, 16 August 2014

To Censure Cyborgs

In N Katherine Hayles' article “Unfinished Work: From Cyborg to Cognisphere”, Hayles' idea of the human and post-human being labels which fall under the fluid purview of history and context rather than “a stable ontology”. Hayles considers there to be four historical epochs of her historical model, “first-order cybernetics from 1945 to 1960, autopoiesis or second-order cybernetics from 1960 to 1985, and virtuality or third-order cybernetics from 1985 to 1995, have now progressed to a fourth stage that [is] the Regime of Computation”. This Regime of Computation can be equivocated to the posthuman in that they are both checkpoints in which we should begin to think about our conceptualization of technological advancement from cyborg to cognisphere- “the cognisphere gives a name and shape to the globally interconnected cognitive systems in which humans are increasingly embedded”. This shift in the way we think about the outline of technological advancement can be thought of as switching from Victor Stone to Barbara Gordon's Oracle (I hope somebody's getting these references). The role that machines are coming to play in their interaction with humans is one that is shifting because the augmentation of machines is developing more towards an externalized input of technology bestowing information, than an internalized output of humans interacting with technology.
The other thing I would like to chat about is Adam Curtis's 2011 documentary “All Watched Over by Machines of Loving Grace”. It was an engaging and intelligent critique of ecosystem theory, about how describing systems via vegetational concepts dramatically oversimplifies the complexity of nature, and the myth of feedback loops creating steady state systems was particularly numbing. What was really intriguing to me, however, was that it was a documentary geared for a general populace with no formal education in techno-culture or ubiquitous media. Like Trekkies about the latter half of the Star Trek film series, academics usually discredit the idea that mass-appealing and widely-engaging texts has any intellectual currency. I believe they are wrong. There seems to be a general sense in circles of the highly-educated that there is an inverse correlation between the complexities of ideas and the amount of appreciation that can be garnered from an audience, but as with these ecosystems, and to quote brothers John and Hank Green, “the truth resists simplicity”.