Reading
Langdon Winner's article 'Utopia or Dystopia?', I was struck by a
phrase Christopher Horrocks says in his book “Marshall McLuhan and
Virtuality” which is 'the message is the medium' (reversing
McLuhan's famous phrase. What Horrocks is referring to is that new
mediums are increasingly being conceived in their usefulness to their
audience, though Horrocks discusses the helpful multi-model format
the internet is taking. In contrast, near the end of his article
Winner looks pessimistically at how technologies such as digital
spinal cords in supermarkets, able to instantly take stock of their
inventories, to distill data about efficient selling. Winner notes
that the true costs are not being calculated- rather that the prices
of certain items, the true cost is local retailers in favour of chain
stores of Big Business. This transaction is weakening social
structures, as local retailers are pillars of communities.
Winner's
own view of cyberlibertarianism forms a hollow look at technological
advancement, considering progression to be marginalizing large groups
of people who do not wish to play active roles in this upheaval of
systems. I do agree with Winner's criticism of earlier observations
that technology is evolving in a uni-linear fashion, as do I agree
that the semantics of a bio-technical evolution creates the
impression that Technology with a capital T (like Politics with a
capital P) is its own species distinct of human agency.
Jeremy
Rifkin's article 'The Rise of Anti-Capitalism' has quite a joyous
outlook on technological progress; humans will move from private
profiteering corporations to non-profit enterprises. Rifkin sees this
progress as something that will unify and communalize society in
order to create charities and networks which will forego economic
transactions in favour of inclusive communities who share. Winner's
article accuses people like Rifkin, those who have plentiful access
to technology, to be susceptible to blindly embracing these new paths
of development as they construct a promotion of power to those who
easily obtain a step up in the world of digital networks, unwilling
to consider the detriment of those who do not obviously benefit.
Rifkin, in Winner's perspective, does not consider the layman whose
status quo has been to engage in stable monotonous labour.
No comments:
Post a Comment