My
final essay begins to define itself- a comparative analysis between
the well-established social-networking site Facebook and the
newly-released Ello, dubbed by several sources to be the
“anti-Facebook”. My main point of interest is the conscious
structuring by the latter to disenfranchise notions of pervasive
surveillance in the former. Ello's manifesto reads as a declaration
for the evils of social-networking being funded by advertising, as
this necessitates data-mining in order to best choose commercials for
users. Paradoxically, clicking the 'I agree' button gives you the
option of sharing this manifesto on these same networks. Laconically,
clicking the 'I disagree' button takes you to Facebook's terms and
conditions. My analysis will assess four major
areas- ethics
of data mining and cloud storage of data and implications of privacy,
interface
design and medium intensity, accessibility (and exclusivity), and
user
connectivity. My main investigation will be determining the validity
of the innovations that Ello has attempted, contrasting my original
observations and quotations from Ello staff, with academic literature
concerning Facebook, as well as other articles on interface and
digital media.
The
conscious attempt made by Ello to distinguish itself from Facebook
stretches from its ethics (they refuse to take any personal
information over a user other than an email) to the aesthetic
interface being a drag brown in contrast to Facebook's pale blue. I
would argue that Ello seeks for the “hipster” characterization of
both itself and its users, attempting to be different for the purpose
of being different.
As
for my review on FTVMS 717, I believe that the course was certainly
one that benefited from the department name-change to Media, Film and
Television. Having deliberately chosen undergraduate media papers
which favoured analysis of films and television over more conceptual
or “real world” processes, I was well-challenged over the
philosophical and more futurology-related readings. Structurally, I
think the topic-order was quite sound. My one complaint was probably
the venue, which could have been in a room more conducive to talk
about the future, rather than the past (or the air conditioning).