Sunday, 14 September 2014

6. To Trust the Tamagotchi?

Sherry Turkle's chapter 'nearest neighbours' considers that the way in which humans perceive life and emotional attachment to have fluid boundaries, and that there is has been an active demarcation between the lines of living being and machine, and that the traditional dichotomy between alive and not-alive has been replaced by a spectrum. Turkle considers that children think this way due to technological advancements in toys- her main exemplars are the Furby and the Tamagotchi. What makes these toys unique to other toys, Turkle says, is not that children can easily project personalities, desires and maintenance onto them like ragdolls or action figures. The Furbies and Tamagotchis have their own personalities, desires and maintenance programmed into them and are capable of expressing these feelings to their owners. These expressions do not create a lifelike toy for a child- they create a life, perhaps not as sacred as a biological pet but certainly authentic enough to cherish, care for, and grieve over.
Later in her article, Turkle begins discussing how people who have online presences, in MMORPGs or chat-rooms, use their mobile phone to live their online life and offline life simultaneously (labelled the “life mix”), and what makes the life-mix possible is the ability to be mobile in the physical world (not tethered to a desktop computer which would interrupt the “real” world). I would argue that Turkle misses this point with Furbies and Tamagotchi- you can take them anywhere, unlike a cat or dog most of the time. Another virtual pet, Neopets, came in around the time of Tamagotchi but I would hazard a guess that Tamagotchi can elicit far stronger feelings of intimacy and liveliness. While Neopets are far more customizable and more activities can be performed than Tamagotchi, Neopets have orphanages where unwanted pets can be dumped (demonstrating, at least, that the creators of Neopets have acknowledged a level of disregard).

No comments:

Post a Comment