Harper’s article “The Politics of
Paranoia: Paranoid Positioning and Conspiratorial Narratives in the
Surveillance Society” discusses the changing paradigm of paranoia and its
relation to technologically-advancing surveillance. His inquiry into “paranoia
culture” is very interesting, as it keys in on the fact that the condition of paranoia
is one which is mediated through a culture depicting paranoia as a sign of
vigilantism or psychosis. I would argue that Harper’s motivation to critique
paranoia based on technological surveillance has a great deal of validity, as
he notes an increase and growing complexity to paranoia, divorced from the two
great Western myths of ubiquitous surveillance- religion, and Santa Claus.
Santa Claus is
almost certainly the first form of paranoia to be inundated to people; the
paranoia of Santa Claus, who sees you when you’re sleeping and knows when you’re
awake, and knows when you’ve been bad or good, forces children to be good for
goodness sake. To not be paranoid (on your best behavior) results in the threat
of no presents under your Christmas tree. The mode of surveillance is as
ubiquitous as current forms of pinhole cameras and computer histories- they are
so innocuous and invisible that it is impossible to escape from their view.
The main point
Harper makes is that paranoia, while producing feasible explanations due to
technology advancing, is that it is often unjustified. Unlike children naively
being good for fear of Father Christmas, paranoia is stigmatized, and the act
of reclaiming the word seems bizarre to me, for “paranoia” in its original
Greek form means “madness”. People should be aware of institutional and
domestic surveillance, but given the recent Dotcom parade of the NSA tapping
the Southern Cross Cable, New Zealanders seem to shrug with an
oh-what-will-they-think-of-next? attitude. Though Dotcom might be paranoid, it
all begs the question- who cares if we’re being watched? In a Freudian view of
the situation, surveillance generates the greatest paranoids when people think
what they’re doing is worthy of punishment.
Get over
yourselves.
No comments:
Post a Comment